This work analyzes the practical results from implementation and operation of a modern predictive monitoring system in high voltage transformers of the Braskem unit substations in São Paulo (PE8 Cubatão and PP4 ABC). This project has achieved the purpose of guaranteeing better company reliability and profitability by applying the right actions at the right time at an adequate cost, since these are the input transformers of the 88kV substations.
The efficient management of substation electric assets demands tools able to show the current equipment status and the future equipment scenarios; this allows the best technical and financial decisions to be made, so the park is kept intact and available. Inside industries, electric power is an irreplaceable input, and its outage can cause great losses to the organization. In seeking maintenance excellence and the continuity of its electric system, Braskem has implemented online monitoring in 2011 as a way to prevent catastrophic failures in power transformers in 88kV substations.
This article discusses Braskem’s most successful experience in applying this technology and in practicing predictive maintenance to increase reliability. The system, — made of a set of intelligent sensors (IEDs), and specialist software to generate diagnoses and prognoses — has been operating at full capacity for over three years. The software counts on mathematical engineering models, based on artificial intelligence, to help in the decision-making process.
|Braskem||João Luiz Gonçalves Neto|
|Braskem||José Rafael dos Santos|
|Braskem||Silas Sampietri Costa|
|Treetech Sistemas Digitais Ltda.||Gilberto Amorim Moura|
|Treetech Sistemas Digitais Ltda.||Daniel Pedrosa Santos|
|Treetech Sistemas Digitais Ltda.||Lucas Pavan Fritoli|
1.0 - INTRODUCTION
Every three years Braskem’s industrial plants, in Mauá and Cubatão, interrupt their activities for inspection and general maintenance of their facilities. Equipment and structures are inspected, in addition to the electric power conditions, which receive special attention with specific activities, mainly at the power substation.
Since electric power is a crucial input for factory production, it is crucial that all assets in the substation are working perfectly. Therefore, each detail of the system is analyzed, such as maneuver equipment (circuit breakers and disconnect switches), insulators (CTs and PTs) and especially the power transformer.
Both substations have only one transformer which cannot have any inconsistency because this may bring great loss to the company.
The actions of Braskem technical and maintenance teams aim at keeping employees safe, reaching the highest possible asset performance level and also keeping power supply uninterrupted to meet the demands of a constant growth in production.
Therefore, from 2011 on, both units started to operate under online transformer monitoring, so predictive analyses could be performed and power reliability could be increased.
Fig. 1 SS Braskem Cubatão/SP – 88 / 13.8 kV, 15 MVA Transformer
Fig. 2 SS Braskem Cubatão/SP – 88 / 13.8 kV, 35 MVA Transformer
2.0 - TRANSFORMER FAILURE STATISTICS
An international research of operating power transformers performance , carried out by Cigré with data from failures occurred between 1968 and 1978 involving over 1,000 failures, revealed the main causes of downtime, both forced and planned, for several transformer kinds and applications.
Figure 3 shows those data for OLTC transformers in power plants. According to those statistic data, the OLTC is the main cause of transformer failure, followed by the active part and the bushings.
Based on this and on the need to increase operational reliability of the assets the variables to be monitored were selected, in addition to the data processing functions needed so the measured variables were transformed into useful information for transformer diagnosis and prognosis.
That aimed at covering the main transformer subsystems and therefore reducing failure and unavailability risks.
Fig. 3 Statistics of the causes of OLTC transformer downtime .
3.0 - TRANSFORMER SENSING
The variables measured in step-up transformers in Mauá and Cubatão plants are shown in table 1, grouped by subsystem.
Variables monitored in the step-up transformers grouped by subsystems
|OLTC||Voltage Regulator||Automatic voltage regulation|
|Power supply quality|
|Torque Monitor||Activation mechanism effort|
|Phase-ground and phase-phase voltages|
|Active Part||Temperature Monitor||Oil Temperature|
|Winding temperature (hot spot)|
|Gas Monitor||Hydrogen in oil|
|Tank and Oil||Moisture Monitor||Water content in oil (ppm)|
|Relative water saturation (%) in the transformer oil;|
|Relative saturation relative to the ambient temperature|
|Relative saturation relative to the reference temperature|
|Trend in water content evolution|
|Membrane Rupture Relay||Expansion tank bag rupture|
- Buchholz relay,
- Pressure relief valve,
- Oil level, etc.
All data obtained by the sensors installed directly on the transformer are sent to the server located in Braskem’s own plant and then, after they are processed, are made available online on the computer display. Through the intranet, any authorized terminal can access the system.
4.0 - DATA HANDLING FOR DIAGNOSES AND PROGNOSES
To handle the data obtained from the sensors mentioned above, the installed monitoring system has in its software an Engineering Module, which includes the engineering models shown in table 2.
Therefore, the raw data from sensors allow the obtention of useful information for diagnoses and prognoses of the transformer status , .
Engineering Models for transformer condition diagnosis and prognosis
|Engineering Model||Diagnoses and Prognoses|
|Isolation service life||Remaining Isolation service life|
|Isolation service life trend (% / day)|
|Remaining isolation service life (years)|
|Temperature final gradient forecast||Future hot spot temperature after stabilization|
|Time to reach alarm temperature|
|Time to reach shutdown temperature|
|Gases dissolved in oil||Gas in oil evolution trend (mainly H 2)|
|Alarms per evolution trend and high or very high gas concentrations|
|Chromatography / Physicochemical||Gas chromatography test offline reports|
|Physicochemical test offline reports|
|Moisture in oil and on paper||Transformer sealing - expansion tank rubber bag rupture|
|Water content in oil (ppm)|
|Trend in water content evolution (ppm / day)|
|Water content in the paper (% dry mass)|
|Acceleration factor of insulation life loss through hydrolysis|
|Bubble formation temperature||Bubble formation temperature|
|Free water formation temperature|
|Cooling efficiency||Top oil calculated temperature|
|Difference between measured and calculated temperatures|
|Cooling system efficiency|
|Torque and changer motor operation time||Maximum torque of the motor in each region of the switching|
|OLTC mechanism operation time|
|Alarms per torque values and out-of-standard operation time|
|OLTC maintenance assistant||Commuter operation number|
|Switched current sum|
|OLTC operation time|
|Forecast of remaining time before OLTC maintenance|
|Early OLTC maintenance warnings|
|Forced ventilation maintenance wizard||Ventilation group operation time, total and after the last maintenance.|
|Forecast of the remaining time before ventilation maintenance.|
|Early Ventilation maintenance warnings|
5.0 - MONITORING SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE
Braskem’s transformer monitoring system architecture is shown in figure 4.
Fig. 4 Transformer monitoring system architecture
Fig. 5 Pt100 to measure oil temperature
Fig. 6 Gas and Moisture Monitor to measure gas dissolved in insulating oil
Fig. 7 Temperature, Torque, Bushing and Relay 90 Monitors
Fig. 8 Server with the online monitoring software in the control room
6.0 - RESULTS OBTAINED
Several results were obtained wiht the installation and operation of the monitoring system we have just described, and the following goals were reached:
- Online diagnosis of the transformer status;
- Plant availability;
- Alarm and alert are noticed and operators act according to standards and procedures applicable to the normal and contingent operation conditiosn;
- Predictive maintenance, operation and planning actions;
- Action and communication standardization at the maintenance area;
- Identification of optimization opportunities in the efficiency of the assets;
- Effective maintenance management through periodic performance and asset state reports;
- Reduction of the risk of catastrophic failure, with the detection of defect onset ,  – an increase from 30% to 72% in failure prediction;
- Consequently, increase in plant personnel safety, both for the equipment and for the facility;
- Extension of the service life of the equipment by quick detection of accelerated aging;
- Preservation of the corporate image by reducing risks of accidents;
- Preparation of the equipment for application of the Reliability-Centered Maintenance (RCM) philosophy;
- Best Insurance Premiums
Since of the beginning of the system operation, Braskem’s plants have been taking advantage of the diagnoses and prognoses, and this guarantees that the plastic production would never need to be interrupted unnecessarily.
2011 – Detection of incipient failure after preventive maintenance
During general planned plant downtime the OLTC went through a complete preventive overhaul. Soon after, by monitoring the motor torque at each tap command operation, a defect was detected: from tap 6 to tap 7, at Mauá substation in São Paulo, the mechanism needed two commands to complete the operation.
Fig. 9 Motor Oscillography during TAP change
Fig. 10 OLTC operation electric project
The excessive number of operations and consequent OLTC wear may cause it to break and even explode.
The technician in charge of the OLTC returned to the plant and found out that one of the parts of the points 03 and 04 was damaged. The defect was detected when it was still incipient and did not cause any other significant operational complications for Braskem.
2012 – Availability of the plant even with failure
During a visual routine inspection at the Mauá substation – São Paulo, an oil leakage was detected in one of the 88kV condensive bushings of the main transformer. Braskem’s whole polypropylene production was concentrated at the plant, and it was not possible to shut down the plant to correct the defect.
With the loss of insulating oil, the dielectric insulation of the bushing is also lost.
Through online monitoring of the capacitance and tangent delta of the bushing above, Braskem can monitor the evolution of the criticality and risk of the operating transformer.
Fig. 11 Graph showing bushing behavior during the leakage
Plant output continued to be normal, for the readings did not present any evidence of explosion, so Braskem operated normally for almost two months until the ideal moment to stop the substation to repair the bushing presented itself.
2013 – Drying oil at the right time
The excess of water in the insulating oil of the transformer causes widely known negative effects, such as the reduction of the dielectric rigidity and migration of water to the insulating paper, with the risk of forming bubbles and causing accelerated aging in the presence of high temperatures; this places at risk the equipment’s service life and integrity .
The monitoring system detected the presence of water out of the established standards and sounded an alarm that told the maintenance team of Braskem Cubatão / São Paulo the oil needed to be dried off.
Fig. 12 Graphic of the moisture along time – the limit of 13ppm was reached
In time, Braskem hired the specialized service and treated the insulating oil so there were no restrictions in operation.
The actions were taken at the right time, they could be planned beforehand, and not as many resources had to be used. Through the software, the quality of the service was also proven.
7.0 - CONCLUSION
Considering the importance of electric power for Braskem’s output, the installation of an online monitoring system in their power transformers is an indispensable measure for the increase of the reliability and to guarantee the availability of the plant.
Using the predictive philosophy also transforms maintenance action planning, making it more efficient and effective, respecting the demands by the Braskem group and causing minimal operational and financial disturbance.
The benefits already obtained have justified the application of the system from the financial point of view, so the extension of this system to other Braskem units is being planned as well as to new electric assets, such as circuit breakers, disconnect switches and dry transformers.
8.0 - REFERENCES
- ELECTRA, “An International Survey on Failures in Large Power Transformers in Service”, Paris, CIGRE, Ref. no. 88, 1983.
- Amom, Jorge, Alves, Marcos, Vita, André, Kastrup Filho, Oscar, Ribeiro, Adolfo, et. al., “Sistema de Diagnósticos para o Monitoramento de Subestações de Alta Tensão e o Gerenciamento das Atividades de Manutenção: Integração e Aplicações”, X ERLAC – Encontro Regional Latinoamericano do CIGRÉ, Puerto Iguazu, Argentina, 2003.
- Alves, Marcos, “Sistema de Monitoração On-Line de Transformadores de Potência”, Revista Eletricidade Moderna, Maio/2004.
- Melo, Marcos A. C., Alves, Marcos, “Experiência com Monitoração On-Line de Capacitância e Tangente Delta de Buchas Condensivas”, XIX SNPTEE – Seminário Nacional de Produção e Transmissão de Energia Elétrica. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 2007.
- Alves, Marcos, Silva, Gilson, “Experiência de Campo com Monitoração On-Line de um Transformador 343MVA 230kV com 2 Comutadores sob Carga”, IV Workspot – Workshop on Power Transformers, Recife, Brasil, 2005.
- Alves, Marcos, Vasconcellos, Vagner, “Monitoramento da Umidade no Óleo Isolante de Transformadores de Potência Visando o Aumento da Confiabilidade Operativa”, V Workspot – Workshop on Power Transformers, Belém, Brasil, 2008.